Skip to main content

Judge Bans Live Nativity Scene From Indiana School District's Holiday Shows (Video)

A federal judge ruled on Dec. 2 that Concord Community Schools in Elkhart County, Indiana, will not be allowed to include a live Nativity scene in their 2015 Christmas Spectacular shows (video below).

U.S. District Court Judge Jon DeGuilio said in his preliminary injunction that the nativity scene of Jesus' birth conveys an endorsement of a particular religion, Christianity, reports The Elkhart Truth.

The Nativity scene ended up in court after the Freedom From Religion Foundation and American Civil Liberties Union filed a complaint for an unidentified Concord High School student, who is part of the holiday shows, and his father.

A pretrial conference for the case won't happen until Jan. 7, 2016, so DeGuilio issued the preliminary injunction to block the Nativity scene from the holiday performances, which will begin on Dec. 11.

DeGuilio mentioned in his ruling that symbols for Hanukkah and Kwanzaa were to be displayed on a television screen during the shows, but the live Nativity scene was going to be acted out by students.

“The disparity is striking,” DeGuilio noted. “That is not to say that the show must give equal time to respective holidays or religions in order to comply with the Establishment Clause. However, when the school places such disproportionate emphasis in each of those respects on the Christmas holiday, and in particular the religious aspect of that holiday through the live depiction of the Nativity scene, it adds to the perception that the school is actually endorsing the religion.”

John Trout, Superintendent Concord Community Schools, said in a statement that the school district was "disappointed in the decision," but would "insure that this year’s Christmas Spectacular performance complies with the Court’s order," notes WSBT.

"Additionally, Concord Community Schools is presently researching the possible appeal of the Court’s preliminary injunction," Trout added. "A decision on whether to take that step will be made in the next few days."

Sources: WSBT, The Elkhart Truth / Photo Credit: WSBT screenshot

Popular Video