Last week I was asked to submit a piece for an Opposing Views debate
about "the best way to discipline a child." If you click on "Articles"
on my website, you can find the link to Opposing Views.
reason the editor asked me to submit a piece for this debate (aside
from the fact that I've written for them before) is because he
subscribes to my blog and had read the post entitled "The Self-Esteem
Hoax." Apparently the experts he used for the debate on discipline all
promote the same theory -- which I like to call "loosy goosy
parenting." Their suggestions include: "Use Positive Discipline,"
"Avoid Punishment," and "Never Smack a Child."
I don't disagree
with everything these experts suggest, but a closer reading tells you
more about their parenting philosophy -- which involves the standard,
modern-day approach to discipline I wrote about in The Self-Esteem
Hoax. So I wrote a rebuttal to their argument.
the day after I submitted my piece to Opposing Views, Fox News
interviewed an author named Dr. Kevin Leman, whose book, Have a New Kid
by Friday, was just released. The gist of his book is the same as my
argument against the other three "experts" on Opposing Views. Here are
some of his comments:
1) "It all comes down to who is really in charge of your family. Is it you or your child?"
2) "Kids do what they do because they've gotten away with it!"
"Today's parents don't act like parents. They are so concerned about
being their child's friend, about not wounding their child's psyche,
about making sure their child is happy and successful, that they fail
in their most important role: to be a parent."
4) "Your child's behavior has everything to do with you."
That last one is a hard one to swallow, but it's also one of the
reasons the topic of parenting has become taboo. We live in a culture
in which people are free to eschew responsibility, which has
dramatically altered the way people parent. When children repeatedly
misbehave or have bad manners, out of embarrassment parents say, "Oh,
that's just the way Johnny is," as if the child's behavior has nothing
to do with them. A child's behavior -- not his personality, but his
behavior -- has everything to do with his parents, just as a student's
behavior in class has everything to do with his teacher.
inability to discipline children effectively is a pervasive problem in
our society. It's true the task requires a certain kind of personality,
but those whose personalities aren't naturally suited for it could
easily learn the techniques. The problem is that society works against
these folks by encouraging a permissive approach to parenting. This is
why books like Dr. Leman's are sorely needed; it's imperative that
parents who feel inept in this area seek help for how to turn around a
child with behavior issues.
If they don't do this while their
children are still young, the teenage years will be hell. And the adult
version of a child who's always called the shots isn't pretty either.
POST YOUR COMMENTS BELOW