Skip to main content

Judge Found Not Guilty By Reason Of Insanity Wants Back On Bench

An Illinois judge who was found not guilty by reason of insanity after allegedly attacking a sheriff’s deputy went before a judicial panel to ask for her job back.

Cook County Circuit Court Judge Cynthia Brim, 55, was charged with misdemeanor battery after throwing a set of keys and shoving a Cook County Sheriff’s deputy in March 2012.

The same day she also made racially charged remarks in a Markham courtroom. She was wearing surgical scrubs and a fur coat. For that incident she was charged with violating decorum laid out by the state judicial code.

“She was off her medication for a period of time and was a little exasperated,” said Brim’s lawyer, William J. Harte.

Harte says Brim suffers from comorbid bipolar schizoaffective disorder and is willing to undergo supervision to make sure she stays medication compliant. A requirement of her probation in the battery case is that she consistently take her medication.

Brim, who has been a judge for 18 years, appeared before the 7-member Illinois Courts Commission on Friday in a bid to keep her $182,000 per year job.

The panel, including five judges and two citizens, has not announced a decision.

“I just broke like a pencil,” she told the commission Friday, stating she was stressed that day. “It was totally inappropriate for me to say what I did at that time – or any other time.”

She said over the last two years she hasn’t had any psychotic episodes.

“I can serve as a judge with full capability as long as I continue to take the medication as prescribed,” she said. “I've had two years to think about this, and I have a different perspective and understanding of my condition. I realize now I have to stay on my medications and see a psychiatrist on a regular basis.”

Brim has been hospitalized nine times for mental health issues since 1994.

Her psychiatrist, Dr. Roueen Rafeyan, said there’s only a 10 percent chance that Brim would relapse now, even under stressful conditions.

“There are heart surgeons who have the same diagnosis and operate on patients all day long,” Rafeyan said.

Sources: Chicago Tribune, Chicago Sun Times


Popular Video