Do you suffer from chronic pain? Maybe acupuncture is just what the doctor ordered. Millions of people say that acupuncture has alleviated their suffering and boosted their bodies, but others insist that it's more rooted in belief than scientific fact. Is acupuncture really the cure for what ails you, or does it only turn you into a human pincushion?
Featured Image:

E² Acupuncture Science Since 2600BC Any skeletal muscle pain can be easily cured by Tradition Chinese Medicine (TCM) Acupuncture.
For 4,610 years (2600BC), Yellow Explorer's time. Until now acupuncturist continues this ancient TCM practice to eliminating all diseases (trying). All the main hospitals of China use this to treat most patients as busy as KFC fast food.
Acupuncture treatment will has needling sensation effect for first few days. This called “DE Qi/Chi” (Arrival of Oxy’Blood---needling sensation). it must be achieved so that Yin & Yang(Negative and Positive energy) can be balanced and body’s immune system has strengthens, else diseases can’t be eliminated. The fundamental manipulating techniques are Lifting and thrusting & Twirling or rotating. TCM Acupuncture therapeutic works and easily cures muscular pain if apply correctly.
Beside sciatica(more trials needed), all others skeletal muscle pains are not recorded in TCM text therefore no “Acupoints(???)” can be provided to any acupuncturist as that they need to advancing the practice and pick the right AcuPoints.
Be respectful, Acupuncture is not a device or voodoo magic, it does not release any things (certainly not endorphins, inflammation, etc, ..) or anti-inflammatory agents. Please do not mislead. It is a marvelous 4,610+ years old, micro surgical tool, etc, .
“An acupuncture is bad science”. not much can be expected in 4,610 years ago, science not even exist. Good science & Resources only available from 1850AD such great scientists: Heinrich Hertz (1887) & Albert Einstein (1905). Since 2005 E² Acupuncture has added a new chapter of modem acupuncture science. which has scientific proven, formulated, verified and even dispelling the amount of excessive Yins/-Toxin can be calculated. Treatment uses single new save disposal and painless micro-needle insertion to proper “Acupoints(??)” and has no side effects, least risk mainly due to accident same as any treatments. No Lifting and thrusting & Twirling or rotating manipulating needed so that patients can comfortably having a cup of tea/coffee.
Acupuncturist must fully understood the Five Elements(五行), Five Changes(五变) and Five Shu/Transports(五输/通) Yin & Yang balance principles. if any one treated by 5 X 30 minutes in 2 weeks and has no relief by 4 weeks, please discontinues and look into others illness.
I have my Plantar fasciitis cured twice by my own EE Acupuncture, last cured was on march/2011 since then pain remains free and no sign of coming back. (E²/EE: Eliminates Excessive Yins/-Toxin/Electrons)
Aren't you seeking and unlock this 4,610+ years old great hidden scientific facts of Acupuncture. For latest update, please check/click on my site below https://sites.google.com/site/jameschongpainfree/
or google search with JamesChongPainFree google sites
Nurses: 3 years of Sciatica (loc: buttock & 5 inches down, 2 spots). Seeking conv’ medical help had failed. Only 1 EE Acupuncture treatment on 30th/10/2011 and continue her normal work. 12 days after and feedback:
"Been feeling the slight tenderness in the area where the needle were inserted. Felt my legs is tired but not the numbness." (50% pain relief, 100% no numbness)
5 weeks Later (email on 4th/11/2011): "Seems to be fine, slight tenderness but definitely better than before" (now 90% cure)
why pain relief if it can be so easily cured. and the cost of curing it is so much less then a pair of PF shoes and not to mention others, .
cheers
James
Bears Jersey Walter Payton Jersey Brian Urlacher Jersey Julius Peppers Jersey Mike Ditka Jersey Devin Hester Jersey Jim McMahon Jersey Dick Butkus Jersey Johnny Knox Jersey Marion Barber Jersey Matt Forte Jersey Lance Briggs Jersey Jay Cutler Jersey Greg Olsen Jersey Mike Singletary Jersey Gale Sayers Jersey William Perry Jersey Richard Dent Jersey Chris Williams Jersey Dan Hampton Jersey Israel Idonije Jersey Roy Williams Jersey Gabe Carimi Jersey Chester Taylor Jersey President Obama Jersey Devin Aromashodu Jersey Josh Beekman Jersey Bears Customized Jersey Kyle Orton Jersey
Lions Jersey Ndamukong Suh Jersey Calvin Johnson Jersey Barry Sanders Jersey Jahvid Best Jersey Matthew Stafford Jersey Tony Scheffler Jersey Nick Fairley Jersey Kevin Smith Jersey Keiland Williams Jersey Lions Customized Jersey Lions Jersey
Due to the wide distribution of Louis Vuitton Replica Handbags , it is not difficult to find an amazing Cheap Coach Handbags at affordable Cheap Puma Shoes prices. There are Air Jordan 11 Cheap a number of different Cheap Hockey Jersey models, styles, colors and Women Moncler Jackets patterns available in Wholesale NHL Jerseys. These Buy UGG Classic Tall Boots are simple yet beautiful designs and UGG Boots Classic Tall Chocolate vibrant colors for special occasions, such as shopping UGG Boots Classic Short Cheap, travel or parties. It is fair to say UGG Boots Classic Tall Cheap that a wardrobe of fashion is truly complete without a Cheap Supra Shoes exquisite. Cheap Columbia Jackets are a symbol of fashion, class and Wholesale Timberland Boots. Women love this Canadian Goose Jacket, as they can show Edmonton Oilers Jerseys fashion statement and personal style.
Whatever your personal style Cheap Abercrombie And Fitch Hoodies , Cheap Canada Goose Jacket in any style, Air Jordan Shoes Sale with fine detail and design unqiue. Green Bay Packers Jerseys can certainly give more MBT Walking Shoes light to your outfit and Nike Shox Running Shoes maximum flavor. You can mix Cheap Air Force Ones and match to attend the Wholesale New Era Hats with your outfit for different Cheap UGG Bailey Button Triplet Boots occasions. You can certainly Discount MBT Shoes meet your lifestyle and Air Max 90 Cheap personality.
Today,Cheap Nike Dunks it is easy for Wholesale Puma Shoes many types of Cheap Abercrombie And Fitch Hoodies quality Cheap Moncler Jackets on the Internet. NFL Replica Jerseys are made of superior Supra Shoes Skytop materials and Cheap MBT Shoes excellent workmanship and its Cheap UGG Boots Bailey Button almost identical to the real. Cheap True Religion Jeans is one of the most recognized brands in the industry watches Air Max 24-7 Cheap such as Cheap Northface Jackets are replica fashion handbags that meet the needs of Kids NHL Jersey fashion conscious and makes his dreams of luxury. While fashion Cheap UGG Boots Classic Cardy trends and seasons come and go, stood Montreal Canadiens Jerseys are always in the crowd. If you choose Cheap Timberland Boots as a gift, UGG Boots On Sale it may be the wisest Cheap Nike Shox decision you make must be Nike Dunks High considered.
jeremy scott adidas wing js wings black jeremy scott adidas wing js wings gold jeremy scott adidas wing js wings silver js wings adidas gid glow in dark jeremy scott adidas wing js wings white
adidas jeremy scott wing 2.0 white black jeremy scott adidas wings 2.0 js wings adidas gid glow in dark jeremy scott adidas js flames jeremy scott adidas js wings 2.0 back gold
jeremy scott adidas js wings 2.0 black white jeremy scott adidas js wings 2.0 white blue line jeremy scott adidas js wings 2.0 white red line jeremy scott adidas wing js wings black jeremy scott adidas wing js wings gold
adidas js wings gid glow in dark g43736 jeremy scott adidas js wings 20 black silver jeremy scott adidas js wings 20 black silver jeremy scott adidas js wings 20 black white jeremy scott adidas js wings 20 white marble jeremy scott adidas js wings 20 whiteblue line adidas angel js wings mens shoes
Welcome to our Louis Vuitton Outlet. We all know that Louis Vuitton Outlet Online are very famous all over the world, for Louis Vuitton Factory fashionable design, beautiful appearance, and suitable for all ages of man and women, ladies and gentlemen. Now Louis Vuitton Sale has become the representative of wealth and taste, we can find any where that Louis Vuiton bags were take by famous stars, successful business men, or fashionable girls. Louis Vuiton bags will always in the trend and never out of fashion. And we are very dedicated to the provision of fashion Louis Vuitton bags which are all in highest quality and the most competitive of prices.
herve leger dress sale herve leger dress on sale canada goose coats mens winter jacket winter jacket
The Moncler manufacturer moncler jackets on sale supply us with all kinds Moncler,including Moncler jackets Women,Moncler vest Men and Moncler jackets kids. cheap moncler jackets Moncler Mens Jackets moncler men jackets style is rather simplistic,nothing more than the length of sub-section,and whether the cap and a sleeveless divided.Beacause we have the cheapest and highest quality,take action quckliy!This kind of Moncler Vest Women moncler women jackets is the latest popular,unique style and very fashionable.Moncler outlet offer this good opportunity for new and old customers.Moncler vest for men in puffer and boom style which advocate lots of warth for you cozy winter.Dress up youself in a changeable style may be what most of us want.Occasionally my mom purchased herself a trendy blue women Moncler moncler outlet right down Jacket which is created with newest factors belonging to the vogue, current moncler moncler jackets right down jacket long or brief all demonstrate endlessly charming
Had been following charms detailed plans drawn up months ago and had been waiting for a bangles signal to act. That signal was "iftar" -- the moment when earrings Muslims observing the holy months of Ramadan break bracelets their daily fast. It was at this moment that imams started broadcasting their rings message from the mosques, residents necklaces said.
The near-term ladies dresses effects on oil prices will be limited. "Psychologically anyway, it's going designer clothes to force some additional selling," Ritterbusch said. "But selling womens clothes may not be pronounced because there's still a lot of question marks remaining" on designer dresses how long it would take for production to women designer clothes resume.
Factory production red bottom shoes rose in July because automakers made more cars. And Wall Street analysts who high heels analyze companies and advise investors when to buy and sell don't christian louboutin heels seem to be worried. As stocks were falling Friday, research firm FactSet released figures cheap high heels that showed just how much more optimistic these analysts are than the average investor.
The United chanel handbags Nations then acted quickly, clearing the way for creation of chanel classic bag a no-fly zone that NATO, with a campaign of bombing, used ultimately chanel wallet to help drive back Gaddafi's forces. "It's over. Gaddafi's finished," said Saad Djebbar, former chanel 2.55 handbag legal adviser to Libyan government. Al Jazeera television aired chanel flap bag images of people celebrating in central Tripoli.
Says that another big plunge christian louboutin sale in stocks could "push us closer to the brink." The Standard & Poor's 500 cheap christian louboutin shoes stock index ended Friday at 1,123.53, down 5 percent for the week. The christian louboutin online shop average is down 16 percent during the four-week losing streak. One reason for the drop is fear that another high heels shoes recession, if not certain, is more likely now.
Critics say they would raise prada handbags costs unfairly for solid countries and could even deepen debt troubles. "Solving cheap prada the current crisis will not be possible with eurobonds, and so eurobonds prada shoes are not the answer," Merkel said in an interview with ZDF television. She added that prada outlet she didn't know whether things might change "in the prada sunglasses distant future.
Thursday 8/18/2011 I will have my first acupuncture treatment for 14 years of uncontrolled(with meds) HTN(hypertension). I am a RN and I am so disheartened with my experiences with western medicine and its practitioners. I had to tell them what tests to order to measure things that could be causing my labile HTN. I have changed my diet, lost weight, exercised to no permanent solution to keep my BP from going up to 200/120 at times. I am a believer that every ailment has a cause, but, western med only wants to treat the symptoms. In the process of taking these meds, the hydrochlorathiazide I believe made me diabetic. There is no diabetes in either side of my family. I noticed when I started taking it, my blood sugars slowly started creeping upwards. I can not take any more of these meds because they will kill me. I have had episodes where my BP was critically high, but yet there was no damage to my eyes or kidneys and I am attributing that to the protective effects of the supplements, exercise,herbs and diet. I came to this modality(acupuncture) because the western doctors and their medicine could not keep my blood pressure controlled and I am developing co-morbid conditions. I have changed meds several times and then made a big mistake in December of 2010 switching from Hyzaar to the generic. My blood pressure became totally uncontrolled. I had to take Valerian, Garlic and vinegar to gain some control of it. So I am hoping that this treatment will get me back into balance and health. After a few treatments I will post whether this has been helpful or not.
If acupuncture is simply a placebo I would love to see the pharmaceutical industry include it as a third control in all of their studies. One of the senior execs at Smith Glaxo Kline stated that 90% of drugs only work 30-50% of the time. Acupuncture is easily that effective for most conditions .
For the deniers, no evidence will ever satisfy their belief about the placebo effect. I surrender to their stubbornness and not their reasoning. But, if a placebo is better than current therapies hopefully they would still agree it should be available as an option, perhaps even the first choice. One can only hope.
.
There is a similar type of quackery going on in the chiropractic field. We did a story on that:
"A tale of intrigue, featuring quackery, shady NUCCA* chiropractors, and "manual manipulation" brought to you by Samuel Homola, D.C." http://3healthymonkeys.wordpress.com/2009/08/10/nucca-national-upper-cervical-chiropractic-association-nonsense /
*National Upper Cervical Chiropractic Association
regardless of its roots in pre-scientific medicine , acupuncture still serves as a compelling cure to those who are willing to pay money for someone to stick needles in them.
Sure... and if someone is looking for some expensive water they can go talk to a homeopath...
ACUPUNCTURE CAN WORK FOR SOME PEOPLE.I FOR YOU HAVE NO USE FOR IT.
BUT IF IT WORKS FOR YOU GO FOR IT.
Thanks to acupuncture, my migraines have reduced the frequency, intensity, and lingering pain between attacks. It was much more effective than Midrin, Topamax, Imitrex, and some other medicines I've taken to try to control them.
Can't argue with those results. Natural medicine (including acupuncture) is the way to go!!! Don't go with synthesized drugs whose only job is to make you sicker so you need more drugs and then Big Pharma, greedy doctors, and the FDA pad their pocket books off of your misfortunes!!!
Some of the treatments I have received have worked and some have not.
Acupuncture has about a 755 success rate for me.
This is about 3 times more successful than traditional Western medicine.
Traditional "Western" Medicine is the biggest scam and the biggest load of crock anyone has ever come up with (save for organized religion).
Check out "Natural Cures" by Kevin Trudeau for more info!
The Kevin Trudeau that has done jail time for credit card fraud and whom the FTC has fined and banned ad nauseum for making false and misleading statements?
The one that was framed by the corrupt American government , was wrongfully convicted, and served an unfair jail sentence just because the government likes to censor stuff that eats into their profits (and yes, the government makes a profit off of medicine as much as those greedy doctors ).
And I suppose all of those thousands of consumer complaints about his products and companies are all part of the same conspiracy? And that you have evidence for the rather bizarre claims you make?
I met Kevin a number of times when he approached a company I was running about doing a joint venture and his behaviour during those negotiations was wholly congruent with his past history of theft, fraud, misleading statements, misrepresentation and such like. We couldn't get away from him fast enough.
FYI here is a link to the first 10 of 111 FTC articles about their run-ins with Mr. Trudeau. http://ftcsearch.ftc.gov/search?q=kevin +trudeau&btnG=Search&entqr=0&ud=1&output=xml_no_dtd&sort=date%3AD%3AL%3Ad1&oe=UTF-8&ie=UTF-8&client=ftc_consumer&proxystylesheet=ftc_consumer&entsp=a&lr=lang_en|lang_es&filter=0&site=default_collection
To have the FTC issue one complaint might be an unfortunate accident, but 111?
I am a long time sufferer of migraines and also some sinus related conditions. I have been through umpteen drug regimens for both of these conditions and acupuncture made a HUGE difference for me.
My husband suffers from RLS - Restless Leg Syndrome. He has an Rx for Requip which has been marginally successful but acupuncture provided better and more immediate results. Within 3 weeks of going for treatments, the RLS practically ceased to exist. He is going to go to our MD to discuss and evaluate his treatment regimen. I am just thhankful that my husband was helped and that we have an MD who was fine with acupuncture treatments.
I started acupuncture treatments about 6 years ago for fibromyalgia and asthma. With each acupuncture treatment my breathing improved so that after a couple of months I threw away my inhaler and was breathing more freely than when I had been on the medication. When I changed primary care physicians and gave him my history he tested my breathing and said he would never have known I had had asthma. Acupuncture along with chiropractic, massage therapy, reiki, and vitamin/diet therapy changed my life for the better. Traditional medicine had nothing to help the fibromyalgia, acupuncture and other alternative therapies did.
If you made me choose between the two, today I would opt for Acupuncture and other forms of alternative medicine. My acupuncturist has helped me quit smoking. I've been smoke free for about 20 months now. I did not use any prescription medication or over the counter remdies. I had tried to quit smoking before using the patch, without success. One of my biggest concerns was that I would gain weight in the process. Today I weigh 12lbs less than the day I quit.
In the process of finding some food intolerances I have probably had for years, I have learned about antibiotics, candida yeast, sleep disturbances and more. Through this form of alternative medicine I have been empowered to take charge of my own health and get advice, guidance and treatment from time to time.
An acupuncture treatment costs 75% less than an office call, lasts longer and provides insight and results. In the event I become one more American without health insurance, I feel that I have a less expensive form of care that is more in tune with the results based treatment we are beginning to hear more about.
Having worked in Massage Therapy for 24 years and Nursing for 9 years I think it fair to say that I have seen more than the average number of cases wherein Western Medicine has not worked as claimed and people have sought help with conditions which respond better to alternative therapies; meaning more than just drugs and surgery.
Western medicine itself has a history of being wrong-minded and holding itself out to be expert in the field of healthcare so that they are living in a glass house and throwing stones; which begets an invitation to return the favor.
Suffice it to say that many of the drugs being prescribed are being done on an experimental basis with the belief that the doctor is in fact prescribing correctly and will make adjustments as the efficacy of the medications is determined. In fact many of the drugs being prescribed will state clearly in the literature that the manufacture has not determined the reason that the drug works, (lack of a plausible mechanism of action)only that it seems to work for some people for some problems being addressed.
Often the claims of efficacy of western medicine are greatly exagerated as well, and sometimes knowingly to elicit the benefit of the placebo effect or simply to put a positive spin on a product which turns a profit. Therefore the argument can be made that medications are often used deceptively.
As to clinical trial proving that acupuncture doesn't work, there have been well documented studies which have shown that it does work, as well as well documented research which has shown that when doctors go on strike from a hospital, fewer patients die.
Many more people are killed each year by medication errors made by western medical doctors than are killed each year by acupuncturists!
The topic is acupuncture, what you write is irrelevant. Can you cite high-quality literature supporting acupuncture for any complaint?
How can you say that an argument is irrelevant when it refutes the statement by the expert witness for western medicine i.e. Bill Reddy, MD, who states that "Acupuncture lacks a plausible mechanism". I clearly addressed the point that we here practicing western medicine routinely administer drugs which are not understood either. i.e. gabapentin a.k.a. neurontin is listed in Davis Drug guide "Mechanism of action is not known".
There are numerous examples of these in our pharmacopoeia so if your standard of efficacy is a scientific "plausible mechanism" then the argument against Acupuncture falls flat against western medicine. Wherein then is the scientific evidence supporting western medicine for the various complaints it prescribes its drugs for?
And if you can't find documentation that thousands of people die each year of complications from western medicine then you simply aren't well informed as this is common knowledge and does not require estensive investigation ~ it is a given. Therefore the relevancy is that a system of medicine which kills thousands of people each year vs an alternative medicine which very well might help people without harming them needs to be considered as a viable option.
Case in point was a client of mine who was injured on the job as a telephone operator and her insurance company told her they were willing to authorize cortisone injections (but not more than three per year due to liver damage according to the western literature and common western protocols in place), or they were willing to authorize a bursectomy (surgical removal of the bursa in her shoulder) before they would consider authorizing Acupuncture treatment for her pain. Outcome was that she opted to take time off of work and pay for her own treatments and was better and able to return to work after only three acupuncture treatments. Too bad she had to bear the expense out of her own pocket for a treatment which was arguably less invasive, less expensive than surgery on many counts and even less perhaps than the potential damage to her liver from the cortisone injections despite the fact that the pharmaceutical companies profits might be adversely affected.
We seem to be getting the cart before the horse here in an effort to protect the turf of the western doctors and pharmaceutical companies in lieu of "first, do no harm", and advocating for the least invasive procedure first. Relevant ~ you bet! Hopefully your reliance on "high-quality literature" won't blind you to the possibilities for healing.
Massage873
I find it interesting that over 80% of people have voted that acupuncture works and these western MD's still say its quackery. I have worked in both Eastern and Western Medicine as well as Acupuncture research and can say for sure that I know acupuncture works. What we need is more research. And also another important thing to take into account is some patients respond instantaneously to Oriental medicine therapies while other require a little longer; it's not like just taking one "magic" pill!
Purekarm offers a bogus argument. Slavery was popular; but it was wrong. Bleeding and and violently toxic purgatives were popular; but they were more harmful than helpful. Popularity is no gauge of efficacy.
Yet, again, I offer an acupuncturist the opportunity to offer high-quality evidence in favor of acupuncture. I posit such evidence does not exist- surprise me.
JJM,
Thanks for giving me something to think about. Consider these flaws in your argument:
To say that bleeding and violently toxic purgatives were popular is misleading. In medieval europe, it was not just popular, it was the only game in town. Something cannot be meaningfully said to be popular unless there is an alternative. Today we have alternatives for health care and lots of people find improvement with acupuncture _after_ they have tried western medicine and anything else that held promise of relief. Next, your comparison to slavery. Slavery was popular in various places throughout history, and (heaven forbid) may be again. It's wrong morally, but that has nothing to do with how effective it is. Slavery was popular because it works, regardless of right/wrong. Popularity is a _great_ gauge of efficacy when it comes to how people feel. If a movie is very popular, it doesn't mean you will like it, but it makes it much more likely. And movies are cheap. Acupuncture is expensive! If it wasn't making people feel better acupuncturists wouldn't be able to make a living without repeat business. It's not good for everything or everyone, but it is good for some.
80% of what doctors do in actual practice is not evidence-based, so what is the use of your "high-quality" research? Iatrogenic illness is the single largest cause of death in this country, outside of natural causes. It's no different than when your medical forbears killed George Washington with arsenicals and called it "kidney failure."
I am a licensed Acupuncturist who has worked at Columbia University on 2 NIH funded studies in the last 5 years. I have seen results and as soon as the studies are published, so will you. I have the field practicing for only 8 years but have seen stoke patients (< 6 months) come in in wheelchairs and be able to walk on their own after a few treatments, I've seen fibroid's (< 8cm) shrink after Chinese herbal medicines were given for 3 months. I have seen enough in 8 years to understand that it is not all purely placebo.
Just cite the high-quality literature with your reports. Nobody else seems able to do so. I expect great things from you.
I found the following paper at the UC Davis health library, you may have to pay for it as I wasn't able to find it online for free, but I'll give you the title and a bit of their findings:
Stern, Brown, Ulett, and Sletten, 'A comparison of hypnosis, acupuncture, morphine, Valium, aspirin, and placebo in the management of experimentally induced pain,' Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1977, 296, 175-193
(p 188) "Acupuncture stimulation of true sites significatly (P < .01) reduced the pain induced by cold-pressor stimulation when compared to control trials with no acupuncture."
(p 190) " No significant pain relief derived from stimulation of acupuncture false sites when compared to control trials for either cold pressor or ischemic pain."
Another:
Here's the abstract from an article scanned in at this site, the article is originally from a periodical called Psychosomatic Medicine Vol. 41, No. 6 (October 1979), you can skip to the last two sentences if you want the main point:
http://www.psychosomaticmedicine.org/cgi/reprint/41/6/477.pdf
"Experimentally induced cold pressor pain was used to: 1) compare acupuncture and placebo
acupuncture; and 2) assess the effect of subject expectancy on treatment outcome. Seventy-two
subjects were randomly assigned to three groups of 24 subjects. The first of two 60 sec cold
pressor trials was identical for all groups and served as a base-line. The second trial was preceded
by acupuncture for the first group, placebo acupuncture for the second, and no treatment
for the third. Within each of these three groups, expectancy was manipulated prior to the
second trial: eight of the 24 subjects were led to expect less pain on the second trial (high
expectancy); eight were led to expect no change in pain (low expectancy); and eight were told
that the effect of treatment could not be predicted (no expectancy). Numerical rating of pain
intensity revealed no cases of dramatic pain reduction. Only subjects who received acupuncture
treatment in conjunction with the high expectancy manipulation reported significant pain
relief. Results are consistent with the view that acupuncture involves more than placebo factors,
but the treatment appears to require a positive attitude of the recipient to potentiate its
effect."
This is just what I found lying around...there's lots more out there and some of it supports acupuncture and some doesn't but it's interesting reading and there's more than enough to demonstrate that it has a basis in fact.
devinv,
NY Acad of Sci is not peer-reviewed nor is it a medical journal.
Did you actually read the second article? It is really the work of amateurs. For one thing, it is way too small to come to a strong conclusion. I leave it to the reader to find the other flaws- there are many. If you can't find any, get R. Barker Bausell's book "Snake Oil Science" (Oxford, 2007) and study it.
The proponents have yet to provide reliable evidence that acupuncture works for any specific condition in humans.
JJM,
I'll take your word for it that the NY Acad of Sci is not peer reviewed nor a medical journal. Can you share a list of peer- reviewed medical journals so that I might confine my research to these publications?
Regarding size, how may subjects are required to make a study relevant? I get different results depending on who I ask.
I'm not an expert on research but these studies seem OK to me; they're limited in scope and they seem well-designed to study something as nebulous as perception of pain. While they should not be relied upon exclusively to form an opinion, I think they're adequate to demonstrate that the issue has not been settled definitively. If you've got the book handy maybe you can reference the relevant studies on acupuncture so I don't have to buy it. Thanks.
1. Is there really such an organization as the New England Skeptical Society? As an empiricist, I doubt that it could be real.
2. For a real live comment on whether it works, copy this link and watch http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yn64xUaRKeE
3. The effects of gravity have been observed by humans forever, but it was not named and mathematically described until later. I guess that Steven Novella MD would thus also say that gravity and
its effects never existed until they were named and "explained." If someone explains something philosophically, and that philosophy is counter to your own views, then if that first philosophy is found to be "incorrect," then anything that was explained by that philosophy doesn't exist, or is invalid.
But wait a moment. Oh,that's right, gravity has not been explained, really, it has just been described. It is described as a force. As an acceleration. That's not really an explanation as to how it works. So if it can't be explained, the New England Skeptical Society (non-existent as it may be) would say that it doesn't exist, that it's effects aren't real. Charming perspective.
Likewise, science mostly describes phenomenon observed to occur and then tries to make predictions. Explanations as to how things work, scientifically speaking, boil down to probabilities that things, in a particular moment, are there or are not there. Electron "shells" are
just probabilities. Physics tells us that nothing is solid and that most of what we perceive to be "solid" is mostly void and without substance.
To get back to the issue of prediction and science. How do we forcast or predict effects of particular medical models. We look at what has happened in the past to predict the future. So, is a death due to medical treatment an issue of any import to societies? If so, let's look at iatrogenic deaths and make some predictions. Given that such a huge number of the iatrogenic deaths in the country are due to medications, we are forced to thus predict, based on the CDCs own statistics, that taking of drugs will kill people. Now, death due to drugs may not have any consequence or debatable value at the NE Skeptical Society. However, if drugs are the biggest category of iatrogenic causes of death, why do we use them when non-lethal forms of treatment exist, whether explained properly or not?
I cannot buy the faulty premise, made by Dr. Novella, that something is invalid merely because the method to explain how it works may be incorrect. An effect still is an effect even if you can't explain by a particular model. I think he would be hard-pressed to tell me how Vicodin works from the perspective of string theory or quantum mechanics. And yet, science tells us that all things are based on such concepts or theories, or perhaps we can go as far as saying these two "realities." So please explain how drugs work from a string theory perspective and I will be less harsh and skeptical about your method of attacking acupuncture.
Mr. Sordean, the only support for your position is found at YouTube??
Hi, I am a licensed acupuncturist in private practice for over 15 years. About 70% of my patients get better (for pain) within 2-3 of insertion of needles. I am not saying Acupuncture works 100%, nothing does. But it is a really good tool to heal once mind, body and spirit with NO harmful side effects like drugs. www.NewYorkAcupunctureCenter.com
Numerous scientific studies support the fact that Acupuncture works and has solid proof behind it.
Mark Moshchinsky, L.Ac New York City.
"Numerous scientific studies support the fact that Acupuncture works and has solid proof behind it.
Mark Moshchinsky, L.Ac New York City."
Fine. Provide real citations (not "a French study ..." or "a study on arthritis ..." but real, traceable research) that support your assertions of "solid proof." You could be the first acupuncturist to cite "research" that is not bogus.
I too was a skeptic of acupuncture. The are no really good studies showing its efficacy or mechanisms but aspirin was used an effective for many years without anyone knowing the mechanism. Ancedotes are not scientific proof but if it works for someone then it works. My young daughter was in pain and we tried everything 'medicine' had to offer. Acupunture worked to relieve her pain. Was it a placebo???...I don't really care. If it works, it works. It would have been nice if one of the traditional medical treatments could have been a "placebo" but none of them worked.
I hope you are never in enough pain that you have to be "shown" how it works.
I first had it 37 years ago when I injured the joint of my right big toe in martial arts class. After seeing me hobble around for about a week, one of the instructors gave me some acupuncture treatments. The results were amazing. The next day, I was a lot better and after treatments for 3 or 4 days, I was fine.
Since then, I have had treatments for an elbow condition, headaches, and various pains.
What it will not do is alleviate problems caused by a more mechanical source. For example, I had a vertebrae in my neck that was pinching a nerve. It would help the pain for a while, but could not cure the real problem. That took some more direct treatment involving a neck brace and Physical Therapy to ease the vertebrae back in place.
If freedom means anything, it is the liberty to tell others what they do not want to hear.
Acupuncture has been around longer than any other documented healing practice. That there is still debate going on is illuminating to say the least.
There is plenty of room for acupuncture and alopathic medicine to exist and even compliment each other. It's too bad the medical community has to engage in a pissing contest with something that, if it doesn't work anyway, they shouldn't feel so threatened by. But they clearly do exactly because it does work but they can't explain it.
I have practiced acupuncture for several years and successfully treated kidney stones (they passed on their own), irregular menstruation and uterine cysts, low back pain, depression and insomnia due to stress. I realize there's a pill for all of these "problems" but some people don't tolerate meds well. As acupuncture has little or no negative side-effects it's a great alternative.
Yes, exactly as stated in the question, acupuncture "works" - sometimes, in some situations, and with little to no understanding as to why. The effects of acupuncture treatment may or may not be in the patient's - and the "doctor's" head - nevertheless, if the patient finds relief for whatever reason, perhaps, in the least, acupuncture does no harm. As a healer, one must needs carry both the bag of science and the bag of tricks. We human beings are incredibly complex creatures. Certainly, there is much we know and understand about ourselves AND much we do not. In the interest of aiding those who suffer, whatever treatments are available, whether soundly supported by science or not, mustn't be summarily rejected if there is a chance the patience will experience relief of their suffering by their use. "Health" isn't simply what lies in the mind of the physician, it is also and more importantly what lies in the mind of the patient. As inconclusive as research appears to be on the subject of acupuncture, I believe the healer must keep that option for treatment open to them in the remote possibility it has supportable benefit, even if that benefit is psychological alone.
I have never tried acupuncture myself, however, as one who suffers with acute and chronic pain, there are many times when I would accept even the scientifically unsupportable if there was even a slim chance it might reduce the pain or give it pause for even a few moments. As I've seen it, far too many physicians claiming to be "healers" are apathetic in relation to the psychological suffering component of illness. It often seems, in their view, a human being is simply a bag of meat which is, in their professional opinion, either functionally healthy or not.
I await either science's total rejection, or total acceptance of acupuncture. In the meantime, as a tentatively effective treatment, I may or may not find it useful.