Quantcast

Stick-Thin Model Allie Crandell Banned from Fashion Web Site

Allie Crandell has been told she can no longer model for fashion retail Web site Revolve until she puts on weight.

After Crandell appeared on the site modelling clothes by BCBG Max Azria, complaints poured in. "As a normal, healthy woman with a healthy body type," wrote one shopper, "how can I possibly imagine what this dress would look like on me when it is shown on an emaciated frame?"

Crandell's arms look bony and sinewy in the pictures, and her waist is impossibly small.

Story continues after picture...

 Allie Crandell models a black leather dress by BCBG  on the Revolve website, but has been banned after readers complained  she was too thin

Revolve said they won't feature Crandell until she gains weight. The site issued a statement saying, "We are working closely with both the model and her agent to get her to a healthier size. She won't be appearing in any of our new product batches or in any of our fashion editorial photos moving forward until the issue is adequately addressed. We have been attempting to respect the privacy of the model in question while dealing with the issue on our end." 

The painfully thin model also appeared on MTV reality show "The City," a spin-off of "The Hills," in which Whitney Port works for fashion designer Diane von Furstenburg and a PR company. Fashion publicist Kelly Cutrone told Crandell she was too thin, and Crandell claimed she ate healthily.

It does appear that Crandell is unhealthily underweight - her head looks too large for her body, and her arms are like sticks. If this really is the state of her body when she eats normally, perhaps she should try eating a diet that's richer in healthy fats and protein, just to put on a few more pounds. The commenter above was right - it's impossible for a normal-sized woman to see what a dress will look like on her when someone so thin is modelling it. And it almost goes without saying that featuring such an emaciated model means promoting distorted body images for women.

Get More:

Comments

andi's picture

THE REAL PROBLEM

the question is not whether she's healthy or whether she's too skinny -- if models of various body types were shown, a severely skinny model would just be a type. as it is, whether she starves or not, her body is being presented as an ideal and it is too extreme for that.

MarkBryan's picture

FOUL

The so called fashion site must be a desperately stupid, and will really lose a lot of money in the sure to be pending discrimination lawsuit.
Like the rest of their models are cows, they're all to skinny for my taste.

SolarSanitizer's picture

I'm wondering something....

Is it your opinion that this woman has the right to be in that magazine? Or do you think she has the right to not be denied access to the pages of that magazine due to her physical appearance?

Or is it something else?

The Democratic National Committee approves of this website.

scallywag's picture

who's really at fault?

Doesn’t this sound cynical? That the model is being counseled and not the magazine who chose to herald her. Is that not a double standard? And why is it that such fashion journals fail to take responsibility for their actions? In fact one could possibly argue it’s media sources like Revolve that help keep distorted images of unhealthy individuals in the public eye as the preferred yardstick. Shameful stuff one wonders…

http://scallywagandvagabond.com/2010/12/city-star-allie-crandell-banned-from-fashion-website-for-being-too-skinny /

MrBook's picture

I want...

to buy her a sandwich...

Seriously this woman looks almost dangerously thin, I don't see how anyone could think that she was attractive.

shawninMo's picture

Really?

A comment like that from you, especially if she's eating normally? Someone like me may say something like "Seriously this woman looks dangerously womanly, I don't see how any woman could find her attractive.", but you've sold yourself as someone that's not judgemental about one persons' looks or another persons' attraction to them.

I'm so disappointed right now.

I don't follow anyone, because those that appear to be on the same path usually end up just getting in my way.

MrBook's picture

looks

As the article points out... her head is exceptionally large in comparison to her body, and both her arms and her legs are exceptionally thin. She may claim that she is eating normally, but her physical attributes indicate someone who is under-nourished.

Nor am I being judgemental... I'm stating that she is not attractive to me, nor can I understand how people could find someone dangerously underweight attractive. I did not say that she was behaving unethically, or that it would be immoral to be attracted to her.

shawninMo's picture

Oh my.

My sister in law looks just like this woman, and she doesn't diet in order to get modelling jobs since she's looked this way her entire life.

You are being judgemental in saying "I don't know how anyone could think that she was attractive". You may as well be saying she's an ugly assed bitch, why would someone be attracted to her.

You're so shollow.

I don't follow anyone, because those that appear to be on the same path usually end up just getting in my way.

MrBook's picture

ugly

Really? So just because I am not attracted to ultra skinny models I think that they are ugly? The appeal of the ultra skinny isn't something that I understand.

SolarSanitizer's picture

I'd feel compelled to offer your sis-in-law a sammich, too

I'm with MrBook on this one. I judged the woman in the photo above as being too skinny to be healthy. She is wholly unqualified to model clothes, and in fact, I think a woman wondering "how would that dress look on me" would be better served by leaving it on a hanger.

The cardinal difference between Book and I is I am being honest about my thoughts and not trying to beat around the bush in PC fashion.

Regardless of the consequences I would suffer, I'd tell your sis-in-law, "That emptiness you feel inside... It is hunger-- Feed it."

The Democratic National Committee approves of this website.

shawninMo's picture

Agreed

She isn't a good model for demonstrating how these clothes will look on most of the customers. She is really thin and could use a trip to the all-u-can eat pizza buffet. Those are not in dispute.

The difference between you and Mr. Book is that you may say something like he did, whereas he's not judgemental and would normally get on to someone for saying that anothers' attractions are none of your business and then call them a bigot.

I don't follow anyone, because those that appear to be on the same path usually end up just getting in my way.

Tom Robbins's picture

jesus.

does she blow away in a strong wind?

Close x
Don't Miss Out! |
Like us on Facebook?