New York City resident Robin Sandusky was shocked on Tuesday afternoon when she found a lizard head in her Guy & Gallard salad.

“I [was] just grossed out,” she said. “I thought it was a piece of asparagus, but then I saw the eye.”

Sandusky was surprised by the quality of this particular salad, since she’d ordered from the restaurant so many times before without a problem.

Though the restaurant offered to replace the $4.25 item, Sandusky chose a refund instead.

Sandusky said she is still disturbed by the finding, but that she should be fine soon.

Sources: NY Daily News, NY Post