Society

Man Who Punched Baby Avoids Jail Time, Walks Free

| by Denise Recalde

A British court slapped only a fine and an assault conviction on a man who punched a 5-day-old girl in the face at a supermarket -- he is allowed to walk free. 

David Hardy, 64, must pay a fine of $1,868 after hitting baby Elsie Temple as she lay asleep in a car seat inside a supermarket trolley, The Guardian reports. 

District Judge Sam Goozee deemed Hardy's claim of his thinking the baby was a doll "implausible" and found the attacker guilty.

The punching incident happened at a Tesco supermarket on Sept. 5 when mother Amy Duckers took the baby out for the first time in public. 

Popular Video

This young teenage singer was shocked when Keith Urban invited her on stage at his concert. A few moments later, he made her wildest dreams come true.

As was described to the court, while at the store, Duckers invited a neighbor she bumped into to look at her "beautiful baby." The neighbor, a Tesco employee, then called on work peer Elaine Hardy to take a look at Duckers' newborn daughter.  

Soon thereafter, Elaine's husband dashed over and punched the baby with a "clenched fist," Duckers informed the Manchester magistrates court.

"He came rushing up and as I looked over my shoulder he punched her in the face. I heard the slap of the punch as well. I said: 'You have hit my baby,' and he said: 'No, I didn’t,'" the mother told the court. 

"He didn’t even look in my [stroller]. It was actually the first thing that happened … It was really bizarre how he approached without saying a word.

Popular Video

This young teenage singer was shocked when Keith Urban invited her on stage at his concert. A few moments later, he made her wildest dreams come true:

"It was only when he saw he had marked her that he admitted he had done it but then he said he thought it was a doll," Duckers added, Yahoo! News reports.

Duckers' older daughter, Libby Brown, witnessed the event and reportedly went into hysterics. She was heard asking: "Is she going to die?"

In the court, David claimed he was "messing about" and thought the baby was a doll when he struck Elsie Temple with "a loose fist" to play and "wind up" Libby. 

Immediately after the punch, Duckers saw a red mark on the baby that was "the size of an egg." The child was taken to a hospital and spent the night there in observation before she was released, the court learned.

Sources: The Guardian, Yahoo! News / Photo credit: The Independent via ​Make Me Feed

Should David Hardy have gone to jail for the assault?
Yes - 0%
Yes - 0%