Should the Internet be Free?

Should the Internet be Free?

If you’re reading this now, chances are you’re online. In the past decade the Internet has become a central force in our lives, responsible for everything from our bank accounts to our celebrity gossip, and with technology so prevalent some are now arguing for free broadband access. Should surfing the Net remain a cash business, or is it time for free admission into cyberspace?

Next question in Money

Dietwatch_med_rectangle_orange

  • “No”
  • “Objection”
Expedia_last_minute_travel_wide_sky
New America Foundation

This Analysis is Based on Remarkably Flawed Data.

New America Foundation

The data cited by the author reiterates information that even the FCC has declared to be

In March, 2008, the FCC issued a report and order in response to their own 2007 notice of proposed rulemaking.  As the FCC itself stated ,[1] "In April of 2007, we issued a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (the “Data Gathering Notice”) in which we questioned whether the information collected by Form 477 provides a sufficiently complete and accurate picture of broadband deployment, particularly with regard to deployment and adoption in rural areas, and the increasing use of wireless broadband and VoIP applications."

Likewise, the FCC updated it's legal definition of "broadband" so that it was no longer 200 kbps in one direction, which as a ludicrously low speed level that allowed people to make massively exaggerated claims of "broadband connectivity."  For example, statements that "satellite broadband is available to anyone living in the lower 48" ignores both the fact that their speeds are often quite low (most struggle to provide even a half-meg of upload speed and are often less than that) and the problem that because a satellite is fairly distant (being in orbit in space) their is both latency and jitter in communications (not a problem for e-mail, perhaps, but a far greater problem for live streaming media).

The author's claim, "From February 2004 to April 2008, the average monthly broadband bill in the U.S. declined by about 8%, while speeds increased dramatically" is like comparing a three-legged dog to it's own race times and deciding to enter them in a Greyhound dog race.  No one in their right mind would look at these marginal improvements and bet money on the three-legged dog.  One needs to look at how the United States has fared compared to other industrial nations -- when we do, the results are rather stunning :[2][3][4]

Evidence

IcolinkLink
1. Before the FCC, Washington D.C., 20554
IcolinkLink
2. 2008 OECD Broadband Statistics. How's the US Doing?
IcoimageImage
3. Falling Behind
2008_oecd_broadband_download_speeds__wall_street_journal__main
Broadband download speed, average in megabits per second
IcoimageImage
4. Logged On
Wall_street_journal_2008_oecd_broadband_rankings_main
Post a Comment

Next Argument Previous Next

Should the Internet be Free?

Loading
  • Yes
  • No
Vote
View Results

Ask Your Friends to Vote

Spotlight

Loading
  • CEI
    The Competitive Enterprise Institute is a non-profit public policy organization dedicated to advancing the principles of free enterprise and limited government.... More

Subscribe to Opposing News

Biweekly updates on new debates and experts

Loading
Thank you for signing up

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.