Is Spanking an Acceptable Form of Discipline?

• “Yes”

  

  “No Evidence Supports the Spanking Hysteria”

• “Objection”

  

  “Rosemond Refutes Four Decades of Research”
  

Rosemond Refutes Four Decades of Research

Center for Effective Discipline

Expert Verified | See Profile

Recommend (0) Comments (0)

John Rosemond refutes four decades of research showing harmfulness of corporal punishment. His authority is apparently his own experiences and his reading of the Bible. He demeans a premier researcher known throughout the world, Dr. Murray Straus of the New Hampshire Family Research Laboratory, whose research has stood the test of peer review and publication in prestigious journals, by calling him “ersatz.” If Rosemond wants to refute, he should do it with facts, not demeaning names.

Next Argument

"Yes" John Rosemond

• Hysteria Rules
  5
• Spanking Has Existed for Centuries as a Form of Discipline
  1
• No Evidence Supports the Spanking Hysteria
  1
• Spanking and the Bible
  1
• Spanking Isn't Always the Answer
  1
• The Debate Over the State
  3
• Rebuttal to The Center for Effective Discipline
  4

"No" Center for Effective Discipline

• Spanking is Ineffective
  6
• Spanking Has Negative Side Effects
  5
• Better Alternatives Exist
  5
• Spanking is An Act of Violence
  7

"No" CNVEP

• Yeah, It "Works."
  4
• Parenting is Evolving Away From Spanking
  3

Most Objections

• The Debate Over the State
  3
• Spanking Has Existed for Centuries as a Form of Discipline
  1
• Spanking is Ineffective
  6
• Spanking Has Negative Side Effects
  5
• Better Alternatives Exist
  5
• Spanking is An Act of Violence
  7
• Rebuttal to The Center for Effective Discipline
  4
• Hysteria Rules
  5
• No Evidence Supports the Spanking Hysteria
  1
• Spanking and the Bible
  1
• Spanking Isn't Always the Answer
  1

Is Spanking Children OK?

• Yes
• No

View Results