Is Torture Ever Justified?

Is Torture Ever Justified?

As newspapers and documentary films continue to discuss waterboarding and other controversial treatments of suspected terrorists, the debate over torture remains intense. Some insist that desperate times call for desperate measures, but others are baffled that such methods could exist in a civilized society. Is physical persuasion ever an appropriate means of interrogation?

Next question in Foreign Policy

You are seeing 1 Comment. See all 240 Comments on this Question.
Regarding Comment
The Question of Waterboarding
  • annalise
    A Harsh Form of Torture

    The issue of waterboarding highlights the problems that ensue when torture is used and the questions that are sure to follow. While physical compications can result from waterboarding the intent is meant to be psychologically damaging with the victim made to feel as if he or she is drowning. It leaves no scars or lasting effects yet there is something inherently wrong with this behavior. Morally it is inconcievable to view waterboarding as acceptable but morals are less important in today's world as compared to security. As long as there are individuals who steadfastly believe that waterboading is keeping terrorists at bay then it will be continued. The U.S. government seems to hold the threat of terrorism over the heads of all Americans in order to make torture appear to be the best avenue towards safety.

    - annaliseUS March 1, 2009 4:36PM

    Reply to this Recommend (0) Icon flag Side: No

    Thank You for your Comment

    We review all comments before they're posted. For more on our comment policy, please see our FAQ.

Related Debates
"Intent and Just War Theory" American Values
"Debate Ducks Hard Questions" Christopher Ford
"Torture is Counterproductive" Amnesty International
"Torture is Always Wrong" Evangelicals for Human Rights
Most Objections

Spotlight

Loading
  • Christopher Ford
    Christopher Ford served until September 2008 as United States Special Representative for Nuclear Nonproliferation, leading all U.S. diplomatic efforts related to... More

Subscribe to Opposing News

Biweekly updates on new debates and experts

Loading
Thank you for signing up

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.