Melandsarah

Who's the Real Bigot? Mel Gibson or Sarah Silverman?

Question by Catholic League
(February 05, 2010) in Society / Entertainment

On today’s edition of “The View,” they ran a clip of entertainer Sarah Silverman’s appearance on Bill Maher’s HBO show. In the portion of the show they aired today, Silverman is shown slamming Pope Benedict XVI for not selling the Vatican to feed the poor.

Catholic League president Bill Donohue raises some questions about it:

Mel Gibson has a new movie out, and all that many reporters can talk about is the anti-Semitic remark he made four years ago when inebriated. By contrast, Sarah Silverman got a pass last October for her foul-mouthed attack on the pope—rendered when cold sober—and had it repeated today, much to the delight of Elizabeth Hasselbeck and Joy Behar.

If they had any guts, they would have aired the most indefensible thing Silverman said on Maher’s show. She said if the pope sells the Vatican, he “will get crazy p---y. All the p---y.”

Silverman was nothing if not defensive about her anti-Catholic remarks being made by a Jew. She said that this “has nothing to do with me being Jewish. You know, a lot of mail was like, ‘What if it was Jewish?’ You know, yeah. If the Jews owned something like that I would be, I’d have no religion. I’m not talking as a Jew. I just can’t help that I’m a Jew—it comes out of my pores.”

Silverman should feel guilty. Just as it is despicable for ex-Catholics like Hasselbeck and Behar to relentlessly assault Catholic sensibilities, it is despicable for a Jew to do so as well.

After Gibson made his drunken remarks, he said, “I want to apologize specifically to everyone in the Jewish community for the vitriolic and harmful words that I said.” But Silverman will never apologize to Catholics for her scripted hate speech. The double standard is sickening.

Add An Answer
  • Oh, I actually get to answer

    Okay. The bigot is still Mel Gibson. This is why. Making a joke about the Pope selling the Vatican to feed the poor isn't an attack on Catholic people. It is, at worst, a profession of her...
    (0) | Icon flag
  • Both of them

    But neither of them want to be. I am a bigot, but no one knows this, because I don't broadcast my opinions on the internet while intoxicated. Mel Gibson, you are a phenomenal filmmaker, and Sarah...
    (0) | Icon flag
  • But Mel said his 'offensive words' in private

    Gibson was drunk and in a stressful (for all) situation and Silverman was sober and on television. Big difference. But I do agree, drunk or sober, everyone has an opinion and should be allowed...
    (1) | Icon flag
  • Maybe both are...

    Who has enough money to buy the Vatican? Doesnt the Catholic Church already give monies to help people? Or is it that some people would rather simply see the Catholic Church go away and perhaps...
    (0) | Icon flag
  • you're out of your mind for even comparing the two

    Sarah is a comedian and the whole "sell the Vatican" thing was a JOKE. Gibson was drunk and not filtering what he was saying. Have you ever heard the term "In wine there is truth" (meaning people...
    (0) | Icon flag
  • Lloyd_weston_43195_2008-12-31_13-53-26

    Sarah Silverman is NOT a bigot... Mel Gibson IS!

    If I called Barack Obama the "N" word, you could say I was a bigot and you'd be right. If I voted for John McCain in the last election, you could say I did so because I was a bigot and you'd be...
    (0) | Icon flag
  • Sarah Silverman is the Real Bigot

    Mel Gibson was intoxicated and in a very serious predicamentof being physically arrested, videotaped and incarcerated by a Jew. He didn't rehearse for hours in front of a mirror, put on makeup, and...
    (0) | Icon flag
  • slaming

    How are Ms. Silverman's remarks bigoted? The Catholic Church, and the Vadican in particular, control vast amounts of wealth. As such it seems reasonable to question why an organization devoted to...
    (0) | Icon flag
  • Equal To or Greater/Less Than

    I'd like to know what Judaism is. A religion or a race? We're still not given a clean answer. If you're born Jewish and cease to follow the laws, you are no longer Jewish? Correct? If it's...
    (0) | Icon flag

See Related...