When Choices Become Obligations
While the “right to die” may sound tempting, particularly when severe illness or suffering is part of the equation, the bottom line is that the terminally ill are not the only targets of those who claim that everyone should have the right to die. Not too long ago then Colorado Governor Richard Lamm made the point that the elderly, for example, have a duty to die. And that is precisely where “right to die” advocates are headed with their legislative agenda.

We Wholesale Cheap Microsoft Windows 7 Key,Office 2007 Key,Office 2010 Key,windows xp key,Windows Vista Key, Windows 2008 Product Key.All The keys are issued directly from Microsoft!
Office for Mac Home and Business 2011 Product Key |
Windows 7 Ultimate Product Key |
Microsoft Office Enterprise 2007 Product Key |
Microsoft Office Professional Plus 2010 Product Key |
Microsoft Windows Home Server 2011 Product Key |
Windows Home Server with Power Pack 1 Product Key |
Windows 7 Anytime Upgrade Home Premium to Ultimate Product Key |
Windows 7 Anytime Upgrade Starter to Ultimate Product Key |
Exchange Server 2007 Enterprise Edition Product Key |
Exchange Server 2007 Standard Edition Product Key |
Exchange Server 2010 Enterprise Edition Product Key |
Office Access 2003 Product Key |
Office Access 2007 Product Key |
Office Access 2010 Product Key |
Office Groove 2007 Product Key |
Office InfoPath 2007 Product Key |
Office InfoPath 2010 Product Key |
Office InterConnect 2007 Product Key |
Office OneNote 2007 Product Key |
Office OneNote 2010 Product Key |
Office Outlook 2007 Product Key |
Office Outlook 2010 Product Key |
Office Professional Plus 2007 Product Key |
Office Project Professional 2007 Product Key |
Office Project Professional 2010 Product Key |
Office Project Standard 2007 Product Key |
Office Project Standard 2010 Product Key |
Office Publisher 2007 Product Key |
Office Publisher 2010 Product Key |
Office SharePoint Designer 2007 Product Key |
Office SharePoint Workspace 2010 Product Key |
Office Visio Premium 2010 Product Key |
Office Visio Professional 2007 Product Key |
Office Visio Professional 2010 Product Key |
Office Visio Standard 2007 Product Key |
Office Visio Standard 2010 Product Key |
Windows MultiPoint Server 2011 Full Version |
Windows Multipoint Server 2011 Student Full Version |
Windows Server 2008 Enterprise |
Windows Small Business Server 2011 Standard Key |
Windows Storage Server 2008 Basic Product Key |
Windows Storage Server 2008 Enterprise Product Key |
Windows Storage Server 2008 Standard Product Key |
Windows Storage Server 2008 Workgroup Product Key |
Windows Vista Ultimate Product Key |
Windows XP Home Edition with SP2 Full Version |
Office 2010 Professional Full Version-Retail Box |
Windows 7 Ultimate with Service Pack 1 Product Key |
Windows Server 2003 Enterprise Edition 32 Bit |
Windows Server 2003 Enterprise Edition 64 Bit |
Windows Server 2003 R2 Enterprise Edition 32 Bit |
Windows Server 2003 R2 Enterprise Edition 64 Bit |
Windows Small Business Server 2008 Premium |
Windows Small Business Server 2008 Standard |
Windows Web Server 2008 Product Key |
Exchange Server 2007 with Service Pack 2 Product Key(64 Bit) |
Exchange Server 2010 Standard Edition Product Key |
Office 2010 Standard Product Key |
Office Ultimate 2007 Product Key |
Windows Server 2003 IA64 Editions Full Version |
Windows XP Professional with SP2 Key(32 Bit) |
Windows 7 Anytime Upgrade Professional to Ultimate Product Key |
Windows 7 Professional Full Version-Retail Box |
Windows 7 Professional Product Key |
Windows 7 Professional with Service Pack 1 Product Key |
Windows Server 2003 R2 Standard Edition 32 Bit |
Windows Server 2003 R2 Standard Edition 64 Bit |
Windows Server 2003 Web Edition 32 Bit |
Windows Server 2003 Web Edition 64 Bit |
Windows Small Business Server 2003 R2 Premium Edition 32 Bit |
Windows Small Business Server 2003 R2 Premium Edition 64 Bit |
Windows Vista Ultimate with SP1 Key |
Exchange Server 2007 with Service Pack 3 Product Key(64 Bit) |
Exchange Server 2010 with Service Pack 1 Product Key(64 Bit) |
Office 2010 Professional Product Key |
Office Professional 2007 Product Key |
Windows XP Professional with SP2 Key(64 Bit) |
Windows 7 Home Premium Full Version-Retail Box |
Windows 7 Home Premium Product Key |
Windows 7 Home Premium with Service Pack 1 Product Key |
Windows Vista Ultimate with SP2 Key |
Microsoft Office 2010 Home & Business Product Key |
Microsoft Windows XP Professional with SP3 Key(32 Bit) |
Windows 7 Enterprise Product Key |
Microsoft Office 2010 Home & Student Product Key |
Office Standard 2007 Product Key |
Windows Vista Business Product Key |
Windows XP Professional with SP3 Key(64 Bit) |
Windows 7 Anytime Upgrade Home Premium to Professional Key |
Windows 7 Enterprise with Service Pack 1 Product Key |
Windows 7 Home Basic Product Key |
Windows 7 Anytime Upgrade Starter to Professional Product Key |
Windows 7 Home Basic with Service Pack 1 Product Key |
Windows Vista Business with SP1 Key |
Windows 7 Anytime Upgrade Starter to Home Premium Product Key |
Windows 7 Starter Product Key |
Windows 7 Starter with Service Pack 1 Product Key |
Windows Vista Home Premium Product Key |
Windows Vista Home Premium with SP1 Key |
Windows Vista Home Basic Product Key |
Just because there are people saying that the terminally ill have a right to die, does not mean that they are insinuating it to be a duty.
Right. Duty.
These words mean two completely different things: choice and obligation. We all have the right to live, so why not the converse... especially when suffering is involved?
This verified expert has perhaps forgotten what this argument is all about. Nowhere in this title is the word duty. The definition of right is defined as an entitlement or freedom, while duty is defined as an obligation or allocated task. Clearly the right to die is far different than the duty to die. The elderly have the duty to die? That is an absolutely ludicrous statement and does nothing to support the argument that the terminally ill have the right to die if they so choose. And then the writer further augments the ridiculous argument with the notion that advocates of the right to die are pushing for some sort of legislation that obligates the elderly to die. Am I missing something? Are all the people commenting on this argument missing something? I don’t think so.
Clearly, the “bottom line” stated in this argument is faulty. Terminally ill patients are, in fact, the only targets of potential legislature. No one is going to allow the elderly to end their lives simply because they don’t want to be a burden. Unless they have a terminal disease that causes them pain or suffering, they will not be granted their request. A University of Michigan study suggests three guidelines for allowing a physician-assisted suicide: 1) the patient must be a mentally competent adult whose death is expected within six months, 2) the patient must request her physician’s assistance to end his/her life on more than one occasion, and 3) a second physician must examine the patient and agree with the diagnosis and outlook.* One would assume that if legislature is to be passed, restrictions similar to these proposed ones would be established, therefore excluding people who are simply elderly from physician-assisted suicide.
Furthermore, where is the evidence that says “right to die” advocates are headed towards more of a “duty to die” outlook? Governor Lamm does not speak for all “right to die” advocates, so the fact that he mentioned the elderly’s duty to die does not prove that the “right to die” advocates are inclined to think that way. If you are going to proclaim that you know precisely where the legislative agenda is headed, you had best be prepared to back it up with more solid evidence than one person making a point.
*J.G. Bachman et. al, "Attitudes of Michigan Physicians and Public towards Legalizing Physician Assisted Suicide." NEJM 1996; 334:303-09.
I do not see enough evidence to support this argument. Clearly Governor Lamm is being very irrartional. Show me someone else who says the same thing. The Terri Schiavo case and the other case presented are harly about an elderly person that we just want to get out of the way. Those are both tragic situations, but they have been going on for years. In the Terri Schiavo article thirteen years had passed! Terri was stilll in the same state. I can understand her parents not wanting to lose her, but was she really the daughter that raised? She is piling up mountains of medical bills that someone in her family is going to have to pay, and she is monopolizing equipment that could be used for someone else. They gave Terri a lot of effort, and they should probably move on. They may even find more peace.
The life or death question has many different aspects. Pulling the plug on someone who is unconscious, and helping a person pass peacefully with a lethal injection need to be differentiated because in the second case, the person is definitely able to make a statement about what they want.
I agree with the comment made about Governor Lamm's irrationality. There is a world of difference between an elderly person who is content with their life and a terminally ill patient who is leading a life of pain and suffering. The point here is about the CHOICE about the end of one's own life. Of course a person who is facing death and accepts it has a right to live as long as possible, but why allow this person to end their life the way they want to and not allow someone who is suffering to have the same opportunity? An elderly person has no more obligation to die as a terminally ill person has an obligation to remain alive.
The commenter has made the wrong interpretation of the connotation of the ‘right to die’. The phrase ‘right to die’ does not mean it is a person’s duty to die because of old age in order to alleviate those around them, it means that the terminally ill have the right to chose whether to live in excruciating pain, or to end their own life and escape the pain. It is not referring to a person’s duty to their country, but rather to their individual rights.
And as far as individual rights go, people should have the ability to control their own life, and therefore have the ability to choose to end it when they are in extreme pain without the possibilty of relief. Individual rights should be protected, and as long as those are protected, situations like the one mentioned by the commenter will not happen.
One of the problems with even the most well-meaning right to die laws is that some may feel it would be a far, far better thing if they relieved their family or the environment of their continued existence. I would, for instance, be very concerned if people contemplated ending their life because of the cost of further medical treatment or because of their concern that they are a burden to their family.
M. Glass
The commenter confuses the right to die with an obligation to die. While many cultures have historically have strong opinions as to the fate of their elders, one should not confuse this with the right to die for terminally ill.
Are we discussing moral or legal obligations here. If the obligation is legal then the Supreme Court would strike down any such law as unconstitutional. Moral obligations are solely the responsibility of the holder of those obligations. Who has the right to tell me that I am wrong to accept that I have lived a full life and wish to not put further constraints upon my family in my decrepit condition. As long as there is no extortion (which is itself illegal) there is no authoritative reason to limit me freedom in such a way.
As a society we need to legislate as if we trust people will act appropriately and not limit freedoms for fear that some people will not.