Who Should be the Next Supreme Court Justice?

Who Should be the Next Supreme Court Justice?

After nearly two decades on the bench, Justice David Souter, widely regarded as a surprise liberal, will retire from the Supreme Court in the summer of 2009. The High Court can have an enormous influence on the everyday lives of Americans, so President Barack Obama's replacement for Souter will be one of the most important decisions of his presidency. Who should the next Supreme Court justice be, and what values should they protect and promote?

Next question in Politics

  • “Justice Must ...”
  • No Objections Yet

Religious Coalition

Souter Retirement a Blow to Reproductive Justice

Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice

Recommend (0) Comments (40)
Post a Comment

By Rev. Veazey, President and CEO Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice

As a faithful advocate for women and families, the Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice urges President Obama to replace the liberal Souter with another consistent supporter of reproductive rights.

The U.S. Supreme Court - the highest court in our land - is the protector of fundamental rights that ensure the safety, security, and freedoms of all Americans. While the Supreme Court supports the underlying principles of Roe v. Wade, it does so by the razor-thin margin of 5-4. (Justice Souter is counted as a supporter of Roe.) Given that narrow balance, President Obama's nominee should recognize that there are a wide range of religious beliefs and moral views about abortion and other reproductive decisions and no one viewpoint should be enshrined in law above all others. The Supreme Court must protect the fundamental right of women to make reproductive health decisions in keeping with their religious beliefs and conscience.

The decisions made by the Supreme Court directly influence the lives of every American, but vulnerable populations often have the most at stake. In recent years, women have lost protections for their reproductive health and safety at the hands of the Supreme Court, and more threats loom on the horizon.

  • Just two years ago, the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 in Gonzales v. Carhart to uphold the Federal Abortion Ban, which, for the first time, banned a specific medical procedure without an exception for a woman's health.
  • Anti-choice forces have been working tirelessly in several states to pass "fetal rights" measures in hopes that such legislation will be challenged in court and the Supreme Court will eventually be forced to reexamine - and overturn - Roe.

Post a Comment

Next Argument Previous Next

"Justice Must Protect Women" Religious Coalition
"We Need More Souters" AUSCS
"A Fair and Impartial Judge" Lambda Legal
"Judge, Not Activist" Heritage Foundation
Most Objections

Who Should the Next Supreme Court Justice Be?

Loading
  • Liberal
  • Conservative
  • Moderate
  • Other
Vote
View Results

Ask Your Friends to Vote

Spotlight

Loading
  • Heritage Foundation
    Founded in 1973, The Heritage Foundation is a research and educational institute - a think tank - whose mission is to formulate and promote conservative public... More

Subscribe to Opposing News

Biweekly updates on new debates and experts

Loading
Thank you for signing up

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.