Should We Recycle?

Should We Recycle?

From the time when you were a small child, you were probably taught the virtues of recycling: paper, plastic, aluminum; you did your part to save the Earth. But a growing number of voices are concerned that recycling may harm the environment by expending more resources than simple trash. Before you decide whether to toss that plastic bottle in the blue bin, what should you consider?

Next question in Society

  • “No”
  • No Objections Yet

CEI

Recycling Mandates Can be Counter-Productive and Expensive

Competitive Enterprise Institute

Similarly, because recycling is so politically popular, public officials developed goals as part of their waste management plans to recycle a specific percentage of household waste. To meet these goals, local governments have used mandated recycling programs and required that certain products contain a percentage of recycled content. As a result, local governments expend enormous resources to promote recycling, even when that means using more resources than recycling saves. Despite conventional wisdom, recycling has environmental tradeoffs. In many cases it can be the less environmentally sound option, because recycling can use more energy and water and can emit more air pollution than other alternatives?   

As a result, research shows that states have spent $322 million annually to subsidize recycling, according to one study. Recycling costs are passed to the consumer through trash bills or taxes. One study found that the average cost per household with curbside recycling was $144 annually; without recycling, the cost of trash disposal was $119. These costs can consume a considerable amount of a city’s budget. For example, Sanford, Maine, spent $90,990 to recycle waste that it could have safely placed in landfills for $13,365.  

As citizens sort their trash for recycling, most assume that those materials then go to a recycling facility. But many times, local governments cannot find markets for all the goods they collect, and much of the material ends up in a landfill.  It is very difficult to determine how much governments actually recycle.

Evidence

IcotextText
Jerry Taylor
“Minimum Content, Minimum Sense,” This Just In, April 25, 1997
IcolinkLink
Do We Need a Garbage Man?
IcolinkLink
Minimum Content: Minimum Sense
IcotextText
Mathew A. Leach, Austilio Bauen, and Nigel J. D. Lucas
“A Systems Approach to Materials Flow in Sustainable Cities: A Case Study of Paper,” Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 40, no. 6 (1997): 705–23. The study contends that recycling paper can mean more of various emissions and more energy use.
IcotextText
Christopher Douglas
Government Hand in the Recycling Market: A New Decade (St. Louis, MO: Washington University, Center for the Study of American Business, September 1998), 7. The Center for the Study of American Business (CSAB) is now called the Weidenbaum Center on the Economy, Government, and Public Policy. CSAB studies are available at http://csab.wustl.edu/.
IcotextText
Bruce Van Voorst
“Recycling Stalled at Curbside: More and More People Are Sorting Their Garbage; But Industry Often Can’t Handle the Volume,” Time, October 18, 1993, 78.
Post a Comment

Next Argument Previous Next

Should We Recycle?

Loading
  • Yes
  • No
Vote
View Results

Ask Your Friends to Vote

Spotlight

Loading

Subscribe to Opposing News

Biweekly updates on new debates and experts

Loading
Thank you for signing up

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.