Is Spanking an Acceptable Form of Discipline?

Recommend (5) Comments (8)

If I'm not mistaken, The Center is, in effect,?a proxy for EPOCH (End Physical Punishment of Children), an international organization whose primary goal is that of persuading state government agencies (and activist jurists) to disallow parental spanking. Their position on the topic of spanking can hardly be termed objective.?As do most?No Spankers, they qualify as ideologues.?Having said that, I agree that?the more a child is spanked, the less?impact (pun intended) any given spanking will have. I also agree that?many, too many in fact, parents spank impulsively and fail to follow up with appropriate?instruction. Discipline is not synonymous with punishment. Unfortunately, many parents think that it is. Siscipline is the process by which parents transform a child into a willing discipline: someone who will look up to them, follow their lead, and subscribe to their values.?Because of the nature of the child, this process requires some amount of corrective punishment, but the operative word is "corrective." Punishment without correction is?a waste of everyone's time, regardless of the punishment in question. So, the problem is not spanking. The?problem is that most parents do not understand how to "disciple" a child. This problem is not going to be solved by banning spanking.?Furthermore, the state is not going to solve this problem.?This problem will be solved?through appropriate education. Unfortunately, in the attempt to create?a perfect world, liberal activists (e.g. The Center for Effective Discipline) invariably wind up relying on the most imperfect of solutions: government. I acknowledge their attempts at education, but in the final analysis, they are eager for government to step in and?solve what they have decided is a problem. When CED says "Spanking...teaches children that the only reason to behave inappropriately is to avoid punishment" their proverbial slip is showing. Any form of punishment could be substituted for the?word "spanking." I maintain that in the final analysis?CED is against punishment. And indeed, if the American public allows the state to disallow?parental spanking, the state will begin to disallow other forms of punishment as well. In the final analysis, we will stop punishing children by destroying parental discretion in child rearing. Ah, the best laid plans.