Should Cities Fund Needle Exchange Programs?

Should Cities Fund Needle Exchange Programs?

Nearly one-in-five new HIV cases are the result of drug users sharing dirty needles, an extrodinarily high number. Some cities have attempted to combat the epidemic by giving free clean needles to addicts in exchange for used ones. These programs are highly controversial in the U.S., with many insisting such programs encourage drug use and increase crime. Should your community be funding needle exchange programs?

Next question in Drug Law

Chicago Recovery Alliance

Making Respectful Collaborative Contact with People Injecting Works!

Chicago Recovery Alliance

The myriad of health needs of individuals injecting drugs are usually unmet and silenced until they result in extremely expensive hospital stays due to the predominance of arrest and incarceration of people for their drug use as our primary means of dealing with drug use. Addiction treatment, primarily methadone treatment, has proven success and cost effectiveness in treating opiate addicted persons but it is largely not available because resources are used to arrest and incarcerate people instead of the much more humane and effective treatments. Syringe exchanges across the country have served to fill treatment programs to the extent they are available.

Syringe exchange, a respectful and collaborative intervention, allows the development and integration of numerous other public health objectives. For example, while vaccination for vaccine preventable hepatitis (a and B) has been recommended among people injecting for decades this was largely not done due to an adversarial/resource draining vs respectful/cost effective environment existing in most places.  As resources have been directed towards accomplish public health goals with people injecting viral hepatitis vaccination has become the norm through syringe exchange programs. 

As well, to this day, the Bush administration has publicly declared overdose death is preferable to action designed to prevent opiate-related overdose such as the provision of naloxone, an opiate antidote with no other effects of its own. The National Institute of Drug Abuse issued a strategic plan Spring 2008 with did not even mention overdose despite it is the number one killer of people injecting drugs.

Post a Comment

Next Argument Previous Next

Needle Exchange Programs?

Loading
  • Yes
  • No
Vote
View Results

Ask Your Friends to Vote

Spotlight

Loading
  • William Martin PhD
    William Martin (Ph.D, Harvard, 1969), is the Harry and Hazel Chavanne Emeritus Professor of Religion and Public Policy in the Department of Sociology at Rice.... More

Subscribe to Opposing News

Biweekly updates on new debates and experts

Loading
Thank you for signing up

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.