Can Catholics Vote For Pro-Choice Politicians?

• “No”

  

  “I Cannot Vote for a Man Who Would Choose Judges Based on "Empathy"”

• No Objections Yet

I Cannot Vote for a Man Who Would Choose Judges Based on "Empathy"

Deal Hudson

Director, InsideCatholic.com

Expert Verified | See Profile

Recommend (7) Comments (0)

I cannot vote for a man, such as Barack Obama, who would choose judges based upon their capacity for "empathy." As Obama said in a speech to Planned Parenthood, "We need somebody who's got the heart, the empathy to recognize what it's like to be a young teenage mom; the empathy to understand what it's like to be poor, or African-American, or gay, or disabled, or old. And that's the criteria by which I'm going to be selecting my judges." The phrase "sober as a judge" is a colloquialism for a reason. The senator implies that there's something missing in the Constitution and our law that must be supplied by the heart -- in other words, the empathy or caring of the judge. For him, the judge without "heart" cannot justly rule on cases about those who are gay, African-American, disabled, or "old" (whatever that means). Given his opposition to the ban on Partial Birth Abortion, Obama would consider an empathetic judge one who allows doctors to crush the skulls of babies who have already emerged from the womb. It seems that Obama believes that the law is about taking sides before you decide.

Next Argument

"No" Deal Hudson

• Reasons Not to Vote for Obama
  9
• The Catholic Church Has Held a Position on This Subject for Centuries
  10
• I Cannot Vote for a Man Who Would Choose Judges Based on "Empathy"
  7

"No" Brad Miner

• “Pro-Choice” is a Euphemism for a Very Grave Sin
  10
• The Catholic Church Insists That Life Begins at Conception
  10
• No Faithful Catholic May Vote for a Pro-Abortion Candidate
  11
• No Proportionate Reason to Vote for a Pro-Abortion Candidate
  10

"No" The American Papist

• No in Every Circumstance I've Seen
  9
• What have the Bishops Said Recently?
  9
• My Reason for Answering "No" is *Not* Partisan
  10
• A Brief Comparison of Platforms Through Catholic Eyes
  7

"Yes" Catholic Democrats

• Two Deep Flaws in Arguments Made By Conservatives
  2
• Three Points are Worth Considering
  1
• The Key Deficiency in the Conservative Argument
  1

"Yes" Jon OBrien

• Catholics Can Support Pro Choice Politicians in Good Conscience
  1
• Abortion Teaching Does Not Meet the Definition of Infallible Teaching
  1
• Church Has Never Declared its Position on Abortion to Be Infallible
  1

"Yes" Chris Korzen

• Pope Benedict Says Yes - It's All about the
  4
• Making Abortion Illegal is not the Only Option
  4
• Pro-Life Means All Life
  3
• The Ghost of Elections Past
  3

Most Objections

Can Catholics Vote Pro Choice?

• Yes
• No

View Results