Does My Vote Matter?

Does My Vote Matter?

According to International IDEA, the United States has almost the lowest voter turnout in the world, ranked a measly 140 out of 163. Perhaps Americans are apathetic, or maybe they’re just concerned their vote is meaningless in the face of America's massive political machine. Can my vote really change the course of politics, or am I just a grain of sand on the massive beach of democracy?

Next question in Politics

Register to Vote: Rock the Vote, powered by Credo Mobile

  • “No”
  • No Objections Yet

Rob Nelson

Face the Facts. Increasingly Your Vote Doesn't Matter

Rob Nelson

Activist/Author/TV Personality

While everyone wants to believe that each person’s vote matters, the sad truth is that increasingly an individual vote doesn’t matter.   I say this reluctantly, and as someone who spent years as a young political activist fighting for change in our political system.

 

I am not saying an individual can’t make a difference, just the opposite. Individuals can change the world.   In the 1990’s me and a friend launched a political initiative called Lead…or Leave that became one of the largest political movements for young people in America since the 1960’s. This is about voting, and increasingly when it comes to national elections – especially the Presidential election -- the mere act of casting a vote has less and less value.   There are several big, and disturbing, reasons for this.  

 

  • The stranglehold that the two parties have on the political process in America, and their mutual interest in keeping power narrows the range of options available to voters…almost a self selecting process that leaves most voters feeling like a national election for President is almost a choice between the lesser of two evils.

 

  • The fact that given limited realistic – or viable – candidate options, by exercising your obligation to vote many voters are essentially validating a candidate they don’t fully support, a scenario in which their votes then become “claimed” by the candidate who gets them as proof of support for subsequent policies and actions.

 

  • Finally, and perhaps most disturbingly, because of the structure of the Presidential election, and the outdated and only marginally democratic process of awarding delegates – in both the primaries and the general election – many votes simply don’t really count. They may be cast and technically counted, but they have limited or no impact on the outcome of the election.

 

  • It’s a controversial position to suggest that the age old American premises that every vote counts, and that unless you vote – regardless of the quality of the candidates – you are weakening our democracy and deserve whatever leadership you get.   But these are no longer absolutes.   Simply voting because you are supposed to may in fact just be propping up a broken, corrupted, special interest and major political party driven political system, and ensuring the seemingly never ending gridlock in Washington and a failure on the part of our national political leadership to adequately address the major problems facing this country.

 

For the first time in our history, it may be time for voters to in mass boycott a national election, and refuse to vote until they get better, less special and party interest driven candidates, and a process that is more supportive of alternative candidates to the two major parties …as well as a more direct democratic election process.  

Post a Comment

Next Argument Previous Next

Does My Vote Matter?

Loading
  • Yes
  • No
Vote
View Results

Ask Your Friends to Vote

Spotlight

Loading
  • League of Women Voters
    The League of Women Voters, a nonpartisan political organization, has fought since 1920 to improve our systems of government and impact public policies through... More

Subscribe to Opposing News

Biweekly updates on new debates and experts

Loading
Thank you for signing up

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.