Are Vegetarians Healthier?

• “Yes”

  

  “Dairy May Not Really Be "Good" for Bones”

• No Objections Yet

Dairy May Not Really Be "Good" for Bones

International Vegetarian Union

Expert Verified | See Profile

Recommend (9) Comments (4)

There was a (referenced below) 1980-1992 Harvard Nurses study of 77,761 women. It showed no reduction in fractures for those drinking at least 3 glasses milk/day; in fact, the fracture rate was higher for those drinking more than 3 glasses milk/day vs. those who didn’t drink any milk. This is consistent with international data of Canada, Scandinavia, UK, India vs. Pacific Rim, Africa, and China. Just from a common sense point of view, it doesn't make sense to take mother's milk for an adult - especially from another species.

Evidence

Text

Harvard Nurses Study reference

D. Feskanich et. al. “Milk, Dietary Calcium, and Bone Fractures in Women: A 12 Year Prospective Study.” American Journal of Public Health 87 (1997): 992-997.

Next Argument

"Yes" International Vegetarian Union

• Longevity: Strong Evidence Supporting Plant-Based Diet Healthiness
  8
• Only Proven Way To Reverse Heart Disease
  8
• Dairy May Not Really Be "Good" for Bones
  9

"Yes" PETA

• Vegetarian Kids Grow up Slim & Healthy
  7
• A Vegetarian Diet Protects Against Disease
  7
• A Vegetarian Diet is Fit for Champions
  8
• Vegan Foods Don’t Naturally Contain Fecal Bacteria
  6

"Yes" PCRM

• Vegetarians Enjoy Lower Cancer Risk
  12
• Vegetarians Are More Likely To Have a Healthy Weight
  10
• Low-Fat Vegetarian Diet Can Prevent, Even Reverse Symptoms of Diabetes
  10
• Vegetarian Diets Can Help Prevent—and Even Reverse—Heart Disease
  10
• Vegetarians Have Healthier Bones
  9

"No" Weston A Price Foundation

• Myth: Vitamin B12 Can Be Obtained From Plant Sources
  3
• Myth: Our Needs for Vitamin D Can Be Met By Sunlight
  2
• Myth: Our Vitamin A Needs Can Be Entirely Obtained From Plant Foods
  2
• Myth: Meat Causes Osteoporosis, Kidney Disease, Heart Disease, Cancer
  2
• Myth: Low Fat, Low Cholesterol Diets Are Healthier For People
  2
• Myth: Vegetarians Live Longer and Have More Energy and Endurance
  2
• Myth: Humans Evolved as Vegetarians
  2
• Myth: Meat, Sat. Fat Have Increased w/ Heart Disease, Cancer
  2
• Myth: Soy Products are Adequate Substitutes For Meat & Dairy Products
  2
• Myth: The Human Body is Not Designed for Meat Consumption
  2
• Myth: Animal Products Contain Numerous, Harmful Toxins
  2

"No" Scott Gold

• First, Let's Talk About That Question
  0
• Fact: Meat is Good For You
  5
• Who vs. Who Again?
  3

Most Objections

• Fact: Meat is Good For You
  5

Are Vegetarians Healthier?

• Yes
• No

View Results