Should Media Publish Images of Muhammad?

Should Media Publish Images of Muhammad?

In 2005, public outrage erupted after the publication of 12 Danish cartoons depicting the Prophet Muhammad, resulting in riots in Europe and the Middle East. While the flames of those riots have since faded, publishers worldwide are still forced to consider whether they too should publish similarly controversial images. How should the media balance religious sensibilities and free speech?

Next question in Media

  • “No Global ...”
  • No Objections Yet

Zeyno Baran

A Fundamental Secular and Religious Difference

Zeyno Baran

Senior Fellow

Recommend (7) Comments (17)
Post a Comment

Quite simply, there cannot and should not be any form of global censorship. However, it is important for both Muslims (ranging from the secular to the very orthodox) and non-Muslims (ranging from Christian conservatives to atheists) to discuss what is acceptable—and what is merely hurtful or disrespectful. If a majority of Muslims consider the publication of their Prophet's image to be disrespectful, there must be a discussion on what message such publication sends—whether consciously or not--as well as the short and long-term implications. It is also worth noting that conservative religious individuals, even those from different faiths, tend to side together on this issue. So in some ways what we are dealing with here is not unique to Islam, but is instead a fundamental difference between religious individuals, who believe in a respect for the sacred, traditions, and jurisprudence, and secular individuals, who believe in the values of enlightenment, civil liberty, and the freedom of expression regardless of impact.

Post a Comment

Next Argument Previous Next

"No Global Censorship" Zeyno Baran
"Publishing is Provocation" MPAC
Most Objections

Publish Images of Muhammad?

Loading
  • Yes
  • No
Vote
View Results

Ask Your Friends to Vote

Spotlight

Loading
  • Zeyno Baran
    Zeyno Baran joined Hudson Institute as Senior Fellow and Director of Hudson’s Center for Eurasian Policy in April 2006.

    From January 2003 until... More

Subscribe to Opposing News

Biweekly updates on new debates and experts

Loading
Thank you for signing up

Please check your email to confirm your subscription.